Sunday, July 25, 2021

Worry About Nightmare Climate Scenarios

What are the risks of not addressing the climate emergency? Scientists, engineers, economists, and politicians must ask this question as they plan programs for the rest of the century.
Engineering a green economy

 

Gernot Wagner writes for Bloomberg that the economist Martin Weitzman got scientists and politicians to think about the worst-case outcomes of global warming. He comments that we are seeing them happen right now. It is the extreme hot days, droughts, floods, and other weather phenomena made worse through climate change—that the late, great Martin Weitzman thought about when writing about the “fat tails” of climate change, including in our joint book, Climate Shock.

What would happen if an intense hurricane hit Boston? A powerful storm making landfall along the Gulf coast was bad enough—people would lose their jobs, maybe even their lives. But Florida has seen hurricanes before and knows it will see them again. There are emergency plans in place. Highways have marked evacuation routes. In Boston, the consequences would be devastating. Nobody in New England, including Weitzman, was prepared for that. Thus, he focused on climate as an insurance problem. Cutting carbon now, he argued, was valuable not just because it lowered global average temperatures, but more so because it lowered the chance of catastrophic events… Now it increasingly looks like Weitzman’s own mathematical argument might prove right for the wrong reasons. It may not be the link between CO₂ concentrations and temperatures playing out over decades and centuries that shows how the effect of climate extremes could overshadow all else. The droughts, floods and heatwaves sweeping across the globe show how climate is an insurance problem, right here, right now1.
 

Intact Insurance looks at the emerging risk and suggests how to prepare for climate change.


The good news: you can safeguard your home, property, and belongings. Certain programs exist to counteract the effects of climate change and shield Canadians from the potential impact of environmental  shifts, including initiatives from the Intact Centre on Climate Adaptation (Intact Centre), whose resources are available to everyone, regardless of their insurance provider. So, what can homeowners like you do? Two things: find out where you stand and take action.2

The Economist also asks “What’s the worst that could happen?” In a recent article, the author claims three degrees of global warming is quite plausible and truly disastrous. Rapid emission cuts can reduce the risks but not eliminate them. Hot as it is, this year will probably be one of the 21st century's coolest. The extremes of floods and fires are not going away—and urgent action is needed.

A 3°C world is thus both a pretty likely outcome if nothing more gets done and the worst that might still happen even if things go very well indeed. That makes it worth looking at in some detail, and the result is alarming. Those modelling climate impacts have long argued that they do not increase linearly. The further you go from the pre-industrial, the steeper the rate at which damages climb. And as what was rare becomes common the never-before-seen comes knocking (see chart 2). Judging by the results of specific studies, the differences between 2°C and 3°C are, in most respects, far starker than those between 1.5°C and 2°C... Just as today’s world is not uniformly 1.2°C warmer than the pre-industrial, a 3°C world is not uniformly 1.8°C warmer than today (see chart 3). Some regions, chiefly the oceans and parts of South America, will warm less; others will get much hotter. The Arctic, including northern Canada, Siberia and Scandinavia, will receive the brunt of the warming. Some more populated regions are also in for above-average temperatures.3 

The most visible sign of the emergency is the increase in deaths from heat related causes among the people who do not have access to cooling measures. The emergency is real.

 

References

 

1

(2021, July 9). We're Right to Worry About Nightmare Climate Scenarios - Bloomberg. Retrieved July 23, 2021, from https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-07-09/we-re-right-to-worry-about-nightmare-climate-scenarios 

 

2

(n.d.). An emerging risk: how to prepare for climate change - Intact Insurance. Retrieved July 23, 2021, from https://www.intact.ca/blog/en/an-emerging-risk-how-to-prepare-for-climate-change.html 

3

(2021, July 23). Three degrees of global warming is quite plausible and truly .... Retrieved July 23, 2021, from https://www.economist.com/briefing/2021/07/24/three-degrees-of-global-warming-is-quite-plausible-and-truly-disastrous 

 


Thursday, July 22, 2021

Climate Progress Update

As world leaders prepare to meet for the 26th UN Climate Change Conference of the Parties, or COP26, in November, a report by John Woodside in the National Observer comments that Quebec has rejected a $14B LNG project over environmental concerns.

Check on government action

 

It “was proposed on the premise of supplying fracked gas to the world as a climate solution, and Quebec's government showed a lot of leadership by saying that's completely untrue,” said Julia Levin, senior program manager for climate and energy at advocacy group Environmental Defence. “This will lock those countries into continued dependence on fossil fuels at a time when we have to be moving in the opposite direction.” After a groundswell of opposition to GNL Québec’s multibillion-dollar natural gas project, the provincial government has rejected the plan. Now advocates say it’s time for other governments to follow suit. #cdnpoli #LNG Levin called the rejection of the facility a “people-powered victory” against the notion fracked gas should be used as a bridge fuel. The idea “Canada can help global decarbonization by doubling down on fracked gas (is) a lie,” Levin said. “It's irresponsible for premiers in other parts of the country to continue to latch onto that lie.” Levin called it a form of climate denial by defining denialism as a failure to act at the scale required by the crisis, even when understanding the crisis is real. “So if you're continuing to approve LNG projects, like the premier of British Columbia, it's hard to not say you're a climate denier,” she said.1


A Post Media editorial comments on a recently published piece led by Joel Balyk that looked at what kind of mixes of EVs/mode switching/efficiency etc would be required to hit 2035 transport emissions targets in Canada. Sara Hastings- Simon thought the editorial was highly misleading. 


2


The study, “Driving Ambitions: The Implications of Decarbonizing the Transportation Sector by 2030” by four researchers notes, “this paper does not make any inference towards the new target as no material such as emissions modelling or reports have been published by the federal government as yet … “The federal government could facilitate understanding by the Canadian public and members of industry by publishing the more detailed projections (i.e., by sub-sector and province) that we assume underlie its sector-level projections.” But that’s not the purpose of Trudeau’s ever changing climate plans which from the beginning have treated Canadians like mushrooms — covering them with manure and keeping them in the dark — while making unrealistic promises which make no sense to anyone who can do math.3


Fiona Harvey Environment correspondent with the Guardian reports a new alliance urges governments to work together to deliver a just transition to a green economy


Ilhan Omar, a US congresswoman for Minnesota, said the recent extreme weather in the US and around the world should serve as a warning. “Climate change is here and it is an existential threat to humanity. We have already seen the horrifying repercussions of failing to act – wildfires raging across the west coast [of the US], extreme hurricanes, heatwaves in Australia, massive flooding around the world. Natural disasters like these will only get worse unless we act as a global community to counteract this devastation.” Paola Vega, Costa Rican congresswoman and president of the special permanent commission for the environment of the legislative assembly of the Republic of Costa Rica, said a green deal would require a transformation of the way governments treat ecological problems, and in the way people live. “Unless our countries, and the diverse alliances and range of powers that govern them, create enough pressure for collective action that changes the rules of the game, we will fall short of the urgent measures that we need to be able to address the massive challenges that we face today,” she said. “It’s important that we are clear that this means an absolute change of paradigm: a change in the way we live, the way we consume and produce.”4


These articles on the progress being made to treat the climate emergency as an existential threat to humanity indicate that the full engagement of Government and Private Enterprise is still lacking.

 

References

 

1

(2021, July 21). Quebec rejects $14B LNG project over ... - National Observer. Retrieved July 22, 2021, from https://www.nationalobserver.com/2021/07/21/news/climate-advocates-push-quebec-reject-14-billion-lng-project 

2

Hastings-Simon, S [@S_HastingsSimon]. (2021, July 21 ) I worked on a recently published piece led by Joel Balyk that looked at what kind of mixes of EVs/mode switching/efficiency etc would be required to hit 2035 transport emissions targets in Canada. 

Postmedia wrote a highly misleading editorial about it: https://cdhowe.org/public-policy-research/driving-ambitions-implications-decarbonizing-transportation-sector-2030 [tweet]. Twitter. https://twitter.com/S_HastingsSimon/status/1417974413509595138 

3

(2021, July 20). EDITORIAL: Study blows hole in PM's climate plan | Toronto Sun. Retrieved July 22, 2021, from https://torontosun.com/opinion/editorials/editorial-study-blows-hole-in-pms-climate-plan 

4

(2021, July 19). Politicians from across world call for 'global green deal' to tackle .... Retrieved July 22, 2021, from https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2021/jul/19/politicians-from-across-world-call-for-global-green-deal-to-tackle-climate-crisis 

 

Monday, June 28, 2021

Behind the 8 ball on climate action

 

The commitments that Canada has made to the IPCC are in danger of being missed.
Checklist for election policy

 

We can assess the plans of our political parties on criteria from the Climate Action Network. Cam Fenton, Canada Team Lead for 350.org, writes in the Medium, about three ways Trudeau can catch up with Biden’s ambitious climate agenda.

Canada has massive potential for good, green jobs... overcome many of the objections that his climate policies have faced on both the left and the right by pushing forward with legislation that both acknowledges the end of fossil fuels and delivers good jobs for working people. Put a moratorium on new permits for fossil fuel development everywhere the federal government can and suspend all government financing for fossil fuels. That includes canceling the Trans Mountain expansion and recouping as much of the project’s $12.6+ billion construction cost as possible... we need to increase the pace and scale of our climate action, and that means setting more urgent targets with deeper emissions cuts. Right now, Canada has pledged to cut emissions by 30% below 2005 levels by 2030. That number needs to go way up, and we need to be setting targets for at least 2025, if not sooner to put us on the right track.1

 


350.org advises:[1]

1

Pass the Just Transition Act

2

Put a moratorium on new fossil fuel permits and financing

3

Get more ambitious

Catherine Abreu & Eddy Pérez report that the clock is ticking for Canada to get its UN climate pledge right. The Climate Action Network - Réseau Action Climat, Canada’s farthest-reaching network of organizations working on climate change and energy issues, has released “A People's Plan: Benchmarks for Evaluating Canada’s International Climate Commitments Ahead of 2021 Summit”.

 

The report, endorsed by 32 organizations that represent the concerns of millions of Canadians, sets out seven critical benchmarks that Canada's NDC must meet. Canada is among the top 10 global net emitters — both currently and cumulatively over time. Based on our GDP, Canada’s fair share to limit global warming to 1.5 C requires domestic emission cuts from 2005 levels by at least 60 per cent by 2030... 2

 


Topic

Canada’s NDC policies must...

1

Equity.

Canada is among the top 10 global net emitters — both currently and cumulatively over time. Based on our GDP, Canada’s fair share to limit global warming to 1.5 C requires domestic emission cuts from 2005 levels by at least 60 per cent by 2030... 

2

Upholding human rights

Upholding human rights, including the rights of Indigenous peoples. Indigenous peoples are climate leaders and on the front lines of climate impacts, yet colonial policies exclude them from the decision-making table...

3

Rapid decarbonization.

The science is clear: We need ambitious policies to accelerate the decarbonization of every part of our economy this decade. The NDC should include plans for consistent, rigorous carbon pricing and for ending expansion and managing a decline of the fossil fuel industry...

4

Shifting financial flows.

Last month, the International Energy Agency declared oil and gas expansion to be incompatible with a 1.5 C pathway. Yet Canada continues to fuel the problem through fossil fuel subsidies, which rose 200 per cent in 2020...

5

Increasing resilience.

Increasing resilience, interconnectedness with nature, and social and health co-benefits. The natural world faces multiple threats, while increasing natural disasters and air pollution bring heavy health and financial costs...

6

Just transition. 

Decarbonizing the economy will have dramatic impacts for workers dependent on high-emissions sectors.Canada’s NDC policies must focus on workers and communities and ensure economic protection, particularly for racialized workers, women and Indigenous peoples.

7

Whole-of-country co-operation. 

The federal government must detail how it will work with every Indigenous community, city, region, province, and territory to tackle the climate crisis as it implements the NDC.

A release from the Climate Action Network - Réseau Action Climat comments that Canada’s new NDC will be judged, at home and on the international stage, by its ability to make the right connections.

 

“Canada’s NDC is more than just a target; it’s about people and the planet,” said Eddy Pérez, International Climate Diplomacy Manager at Climate Action Network Canada. “Time is running out for tackling the climate crisis. Will the government step up and show the leadership we need before it’s too late? Canada has a track record of failing to follow through on climate promises. With a strong NDC, we can break that cycle.”3

The prospect of a federal election in the near future is an opportunity to compare party platforms to the policy Canada needs to honour our commitments to reducing the impact of climate change on our planet.

 

References

1

(2021, February 3). Three ways Trudeau can catch up with Biden's ambitious climate .... Retrieved February 4, 2021, from https://medium.com/@350canada/three-ways-trudeau-can-catch-up-with-bidens-ambitious-climate-agenda-ab197642a6d0?source=rss-------1

2

(2021, June 28). Clock is ticking for Canada to get its UN climate pledge right .... Retrieved June 28, 2021, from https://www.nationalobserver.com/2021/06/28/opinion/clock-ticking-canada-get-its-un-climate-pledge-right

3

(2021, June 28). A People's Plan: Benchmarks for Evaluating Canada's International .... Retrieved June 28, 2021, from https://climateactionnetwork.ca/2021/06/28/a-peoples-plan-benchmarks-for-evaluating-canadas-international-climate-commitments-ahead-of-2021-summit/

 

Saturday, June 26, 2021

Climate change action by Canadian governments and institutions

 How will we measure the sincerity of promises to act on climate change in the upcoming elections?  Charlie Smith writes that Seth Klein believes that many of the authors scrupulously avoid linking the fight to reduce greenhouse-gas emissions to struggles for social justice and against inequality. Klein set out to do something radically different in his new book, A Good War: Mobilizing Canada for the Climate Emergency.


Drawing upon the country’s experience in the Second World War, he proposes to replicate the same can-do mindset to enlist masses of Canadians, as well as governments, to seriously confront the existential crisis generated by a warming planet. “This is a life-and-death struggle,” Klein tells the Straight by phone, “and it deserves to be told with some passion. I tried to bring some of that into it. I tried to write something that would touch the heart as well as the head.” During the Second World War, the government, led by Mackenzie King, threw out the rulebook. It created more than 28 Crown corporations to meet the needs of the war effort, which was led by munitions and supply minister C. D. Howe.1


In his book, Klein points out that the greatest income inequality in the 20th century occurred in 1938—just one year before the war began.


"when you think about our wartime experience, because Canada didn’t just offer training and relocation allowances to people then — we actively connected people to the jobs that the wartime mobilization…" - A Good War by Seth Klein.2

A Good War: Mobilizing Canada for the Climate Emergency.

The Climate Emergency Unit believe it is time for Canada to enter true #ClimateEmergency mode. They have produced a new video ( https://youtu.be/XUJw5cLyfEk )to show what that would look like.

 

This hopeful video explains how 4 key lessons for Canada's WW2 mobilization can be used to take action on climate change by Canadian governments and institutions. We all know that climate change is real and we need to dramatically reduce our greenhouse gases as soon as possible, but Canada's emissions have only stagnated since the world agreed to work together on this climate emergency. Using these lessons from WW2, we can envision what true climate action looks like.3


Action by the government and other institutions to seriously address the Climate Emergency would have the characteristics of the effort 80 years ago to win WWII.

 

References

 

1

(2020, September 9). Vancouver author Seth Klein wants us all to wage A Good War to .... Retrieved February 6, 2021, from https://www.straight.com/living/vancouver-author-seth-klein-wants-us-all-to-wage-a-good-war-to-prevent-a-climate-catastrophe 

2

Klein, Seth. (2020) A Good War: Mobilizing Canada for the Climate Emergency. Toronto, ON:ECW Press. 

3

(2021, June 23). 4 Hopeful Lessons from WW2 to Confront Climate Change - YouTube. Retrieved June 26, 2021, from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XUJw5cLyfEk